I haven't found your deleted subs for episode 1, but I did find your deleted subs for episode 2:https://subscene.com/subtitles/justifie ... sh/3131482
https://subscene.com/subtitles/justifie ... sh/3131484
these were deleted and I was the first to upload them.
I agree, there should be some communication and this should be fair, respectful and clear, from both sides. And warnings and limitations should be reasonable. That being said, it IS the admin task and to run their language section to their own discretion, within certain limits of common sense and reasonability.What comes those so called semi dupes that's a problem because opensubtitleuploaders won't know what is semi dupes. And then admins send angry emails and, set limits for uploders. If you try to explain this, then admins get angry and gives warnings. It's not right that one person makes the ruling to give warnings or set limits.
Yes, technically, admins can delete comments. It depends on the actual comment if they should.Questions: Can admins delete comments that are given to them because M_I_S has deleted my comments on his or her profile and uploaded subtitles? Normal users can't. my comment wasn't vulgar or anything like that.
Once again, I don't know what is going on exactly between you and M_I_S. And yes, it would be nice if M_I_S would comment on this.Secondly, is it normal to say this about M_I_S in my profile? (We're down with you Any especially popular or blockbuster's sub-upload in the English section will be deleted.)You can see all the comments on my profile. I don't think that I have used vulgar words. PS: I would like to hear comments from uploaders and administrators. Of course, M_I_S should explain his or her actions too.
I don't think Explosiveskull explained. Already from the very first two comments in the discussion on the profile page of Class123, it is clear for me that Class123 did not understand:His performance is clear and does not need any explanation.
He was given many chances, but the same way and the same words.
Dear Master EXP explaind to him before,
I think it's bad practice to assume and expect that users know and understand what admins know and understand. A good admin explains well and clear. Only AFTER THAT, we can assume the user knows and expect a change in behavior from the uploader.but which good uploader that don't knows diffrence between dupe and semi dupe ?
Saying things like "you don't have the balls to correct it" and "What a hell is wrong whit you." is not very sweet. But I understand the frustration of Class123. He feels treated unfairly by admins in a power position, who refuse to explain, but rigidly stick to their statements and avoid an adult discussion. I would get upset, too. I think if Class123 was explained WELL about semi-duplicates, he would have understood and no rude behavior would have occurred.but behavior rude never tolerant.
With "limited", do you mean "any especially popular and blockbusters' s sub upload in English section will be deleted."?So I only just a bit limited him and he is free to upload whatever he likes, even in the English section but In Eng Section he is currently a bit limited.
I agree.I didn't get anything out of that explanation of why M_I_Se deleted my comment; there was nothing against the rules.
I am not sure if that's what M_I_S meant with "disturbance". I'm also not sure if M_I_S did something WRONG by replacing your version with his. If this is about the subtitle you referred to before, it was not a (semi-)duplicate but apparently an improved version.M_I_S comment after the warning says that I have disturbed the section. commenting on his or her wrongdoing. Is that against the rules?
I agree: if users should not upload semi-duplicates, admins shouldn't do that neither. But only if those are semi-duplicates, not significantly improved subs.Deleiting my uploads, then say they are duplicates and then uploads hes or shes own duplicates it's like a slap in the face
I am tryingM_I_S has given answer. What now?. I want all warnings and limitations removed. The reason is simple: I haven't broken any rules.
Can you help me? with this.
All the important work that is done in the English sec is done with the coordination of the head of the section(Dear Scooby 007) and in the next step with the coordination of the Dear OSS.
I think there is. I tried to mediate, create mutual understanding, give arguments, and come to a reasonable solution which I think both could live with.there is nothing to agree or disagree.![]()
Apparently notTrust me we can handle it.
This was already in effect, for a long time, for everyoneIf I continue to upload on this site, I have to always check the site to see if subs already exist. Is this rule now in effect?
You mean rules about what is a semi-dupe and what is not?PS: is there a link to the rules?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 20 guests